
On a follow up call with a mortgage banker friend of mine the other day in Vancouver, Washington, I asked him about a couple who he had referred me to a month or so back. To protect their identities, I will just call them the Jones family. At the time, they were in search of a new home in the Vancouver, Washington area. They did the right thing and contacted a lender (my buddy) to find out how much they would qualify to borrow and to get pre approved before they started their search. He learned that they didn't have a real estate agent yet and he referred them to me. I spoke with them once and they told me that they had already found an agent who was working with them to find their new Vancouver, Washington home.
That was the last that I had heard from and they cut off contact with my lender friend for a little over a month. Then, one day out of the blue they returned his call and told him the great news; they had found the perfect home, made an offer, and were in a contract. Best of all was that they did it all by themselves without the aid a real estate agent. My friend congratulated them and then asked them why they didn't use an agent.

Mr. Jones gleefully told him, "It is a for sale by owner and they wanted $350,000 for the house. We got it for $330,000 because we didn't use an agent! We saved $20,000."
When my friend asked if the seller was paying any closing cost, they responded, "No, it is a great deal without them paying closing costs."
Here is the summary of what happened: The Jones family found their perfect Vancouver, Washington home which was a FSBO. The owner wanted $350,000 but told them he would accept $330,000 if they didn't use a real estate agent. They took it "hook, line, and sinker!" Good thing there was a bank involved because two weeks later it only appraised at $308,000. Mr. Jones, being the STELLAR negotiation expert that he is, convinced the seller to bring the price down to $315,000 and asked the bank to reappraise the property. They pointed out to the bank that the home had a new roof, fresh paint, and a remodeled kitchen with granite counters. The buyers had a 20% down payment so the appraiser squinted his eyes really hard and stretched the value to $314,000 which the seller accepted.
After hearing the story, I comp'd the home myself. The appraiser wasn't squinting to get that value, HE WAS BLIND! That Vancouver, Washington dream house wasn't worth one penny over $304,000!
Not only did they over pay by at least $10,000 but they never even asked the seller to contribute to their closing costs. In this market, how could buyers ever fall into this trap?

Photo credits:
Castle - Magda
FSBO - Casey Serin